AFL Tipping

Our AFL experts tackle some of the burning questions ahead of Round 15.

Is Jake Stringer a top 10 player in the league?

Rohan Connolly: In terms of ability, yes. In terms of performance, which is really how you have to measure it, no. In fairness to him, though, when he's been fully fit at Essendon, his performances have been pretty consistent. And games like last Sunday's really do remind you just how much pure football talent he has, a great combination of strength and footy smarts and instinct. There's certainly not many others who can do the sort of stuff he does.

h1">>Editor's Picks1 Related

Jake Michaels: The closest thing we have to Dustin Martin -- the consnsus No. 1 player in the league -- is Stringer. That's not saying he's the second best player in the AFL (he's not) but he plays with that similar bullocking style, which seemingly cannot be stopped when in top gear. Both start at the centre bounces and push forward whre they do their best work. Unfortunately, consistency and injuries have let Stringer down. If he can find a way to win 25 percent more ball, I have no doubt he's a top 10 player, but right now he's in that 11-20 band.

Matt Walsh: Considering he's had a top 10 best and fairest finish once in his career, it would seem he's barely a top 10 player at his own club! He's great when on, but as the stat suggests, far too inconsistent. Dusty does it most weeks -- as does Toby Greene and Bont -- while Danger, Fyfe and a dozen others are all well ahead of Stinger.

Jesse Robinson: Nope. Stringer has the ability to put it all together and be a match winner on his day but he's far too inconsistent to be a top 10 player. Add to that he's only collected a total of 13 Brownlow votes in his career, I think he's still got a bit of work to do before he enters the Fyfe, Martin, Patrick Dangerfield category. He may sneak in to the top 10 forwards category.

figure">>
Is Jake Stringer of the Bombers a top 10 player in the league? Steve Bell/Getty Images

Is Stuart Dew the man to coach the Suns for the next four years?

RC: Really tough one to answer, because I'm convinced a lot of their problems are a consequence of the location of the club, and the fact there just isn't that buzz, nor real intense pressure around the players to perform. The sad part for Dew is things might have slipped to the stage where it does take a real marquee name as coach to have people keep paying attention. Not his fault, but he may end up paying the price.

JM: Yet again, I'm going to say coaches can't make that much of a difference without the right personnel on the park. The Suns have way more issues at the moment than who is in charge, but someone has to take the fall and I expect it will be Dew. Will he be there in 2025? No, I don't think so.

MW: Get the player retention issues sorted, field a side that's not the youngest or second-youngest in the league, and avoid a 'go-home-five' situation and the coaching will take care of itself. I like the Neil Craig role, and Dew is, from all reports, a switched-on operator. He's been in charge for nearly four years, I'd love to see him mature and get better with this current list over another four.

JR: Four years is an incredibly long time in football, but for now the Suns should stick with Dew. It's obvious the players like him, he's a good man manager, which could be vital in player retention, which is a big area of concern for them. We've seen some lacklustre performances from the Suns but let's not forget some inspired efforts, like the win against Collingwood. The Suns need a bit of consistency, so I wouldn't be tipping Dew out any time soon. If there is concerns about the Suns' play style or tactics, then perhaps Dew's assistant coaching staff need to be looked at, much like Richmond did at the end of 2016.

h1">>AFL on ESPN

Love the AFL? Australian users can personalise their ESPN experience by downloading the App. Get live scores, news and videos

ANYWHERE ,

ANYTIME .

• Download ESPN from Google Play Store

• Download ESPN from iTunes App Store

Get AFL news and more in your inbox

• Head to ESPN's Home of AFL

Josh Dunkley's 'rock bottom': 'Was told to jump off a bridge'

Which injury harms their side's flag hopes more - Robbie Gray or Mitch Duncan?

RC: Line ball, but I'd probably argue Gray. I think Duncan probably contributes more to the Cats right now than Gray does Port, but I also reckon the Cats can better cover his absence in terms of pure possessions. With Gray, the whole left without him isn't so much about numbers of touches as goalkicking, but even more so, about leadership and coolness under pressure. I think in an area in which the Power are still a little suspect, Gray provides a lot of that.

JM: Both are terrific players but I think Port will struggle more to fill the void left by Gray. Let's face it, he's a goalkicker and a damn good one at that! Ken Hinkley's side has had its issues in front of the sticks, so losing a player of Gray's ability and class is a huge blow. Plus, given the Cats are more likely to finish top four than Port, the loss of Duncan shouldn't be too catastrophic in the run to September.

MW: These days, Gray is the X-factor for Port - the cherry on top. Duncan is a tough nut and remains a mainstay of the Cats' engine room. I think Duncan, but only just.

JR: The Cats probably have a stronger chance of winning a flag this year so Duncan is a big out, but as far as reliance on a single player and match winning ability, the Power will miss Gray massively. Losing him hurts their premiership chances as much as losing Charlie Dixon or Ollie Wines would. They'll need to do their best to stay in contention and hope he's right for finals.

figure">>
Mitch Duncan is set to miss two months of action. Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images

If you had to choose a player to kick after the siren from 40m out on a 45 degree angle, who are you choosing?

RC: How can you go past Gary Rohan after last Friday? His performance levels may not always have been consistent, but boy his goalkicking has, right from his first season at Sydney, when he finished the year with 7.1. He's got career numbers of 165.92 (that's 64 percent accuracy), he's up to 22.8 this season, and he's got a beautiful, fluid run-up and kicking technique. I can't remember feeling as confident about a post-siren kicking being a goal than I was with him against the Bulldogs.

JM: David Mundy is the man I want. He's done it before and I have no doubt he can do it again. The other player I wouldn't mind having kick after the bell is Toby Greene, who loves the big stage and would thrive in such a moment. You just know he'd slot it!

MW: Jack Riewoldt has one of the best set shots in the game and he never looks flustered when lining up for any kick at goal. With maturity and age has come an understanding that he doesn't need to do too much - goalkicking is a relatively simple skill. He blocks out distraction, noise and nerves like not many others.

JR: My head says Mundy but my heart says West Coast's Josh Kennedy and not just for his recent heroics. He's been arguably the most reliable key forward of our era when he's on the park and whenever he's got the ball in hand and lining up for goal, you can feel pretty confident there's six points going up on the score board.

Source : https://africa.espn.com/afl/story/_/id/31677156/afl-round-15-round-table-jake-stringer-top-10-player-league-stuart-dew-man-get-gold-coast-suns-mess

1892
AFL Round Table: Is Jake Stringer a top 10 player in the league? Is Stuart Dew the man to get the Suns out of this mess?

Source:ESPN

AFL Round Table: Is Jake Stringer a top 10 player in the league? Is Stuart Dew the man to get the Suns out of this mess?

Shoulder operation for AFL veteran Geary

Source:ESPN

Shoulder operation for AFL veteran Geary

Expert AFL Round 14 tips: Little respect for second-placed side as two make bold upset calls

Source:Fox Sports

Expert AFL Round 14 tips: Little respect for second-placed side as two make bold upset calls

One year on from the AFLs Black Lives Matter protests: whats changed?

Source:ESPN.com

One year on from the AFLs Black Lives Matter protests: whats changed?